Simon Thompson receiving 1st place in the prestigious John Joyce Award at ISAKOS 2015.

Simon Thompson receiving 1st place in the prestigious John Joyce Award at ISAKOS 2015.

Simon M Thompson
John J. Joyce Award 2015 FIRST PLACE Winner, at ISAKOS Congress 2015

A 20 Year Longitudinal Prospective Evaluation of Endoscopic ACL Reconstruction with Patellar Tendon Autograft

Simon M. Thompson, MBBS, BSc(Hon), MSc MD(Res), FRCS(Tr & Orth), AUSTRALIA
Lucy J. Salmon, PhD; Alison Waller, BAppSci(Physio); Justin P. Roe, FRACS, A/Prof (UNSW); James M. Linklater, MBBS (Hons), FRANZCR; Leo A. Pinczewski, FRACS.
North Sydney Orthopaedic and Sports Medicine Centre, Sydney, NSW, AUSTRALIA

Over the long term ACL reconstruction with the patellar tendon graft was associated with good clinical outcomes, but a high rate of contralateral ACL injury.


This longitudinal prospective study reports the outcome of isolated anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction using middle-third patellar tendon autograft in 90 patients over 20 years.

Between January 1993 and April 1994, 333 consecutive patients underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Patients with associated ligamentous injury requiring surgery, previous meniscectomy, or meniscal injury requiring more than one third meniscectomy; chondral injury diagnosed at arthroscopy; and an abnormal contralateral knee were excluded. Ninety patients met the inclusion criteria. Evaluation was conducted annually for 5 years, then at 7, 10, 15 and 20 years after surgery. Outcomes included range of motion, Lachman and pivot-shift tests, instrumented ligament testing, single-legged hop test, Lysholm Knee Score, the International Knee Documentation Committee evaluation, and radiographic assessment.

At 20 years after ACL reconstruction 31 patients had sustained another ACL injury, 8 to the index limb and 27 to the contralateral limb, including 3 who injured both the reconstructed and contralateral ACL. The mean IKDC score at 20 years was 86 and 50% of subjects reported regular participation in strenuous to very strenuous activities. Kneeling pain was present in 62%. Radiographic degenerative change was found in 60%. IKDC ligamentous examination was grade A in 82% and grade B in 16% of those without further ACL injury. Significant gender differences were apparent at 20 years after surgery. When compared to males, females had higher ACL graft survival at 20 years (83% v 97%, HR 7.1, p=0.06). However females also reported significantly poorer mean IKDC subjective score (90 v 83, p=0.03), more activity related pain (p=0.02), and swelling (p=0.05) and lower regular activity level (p=0.04) than males.

The incidence of further ACL injury 20 years after ACL reconstruction was high, and more commonly occurs in the contralateral ACL than the reconstructed ACL graft. Females demonstrate a trend towards lower rates of further ACL compared to males, this may be related to less participation in high risk sports due to symptomatic limitation. Kneeling pain remained a persistent symptom over 20 years. Radiographic osteoarthritis was evident in the majority of subjects but symptomatic osteoarthritic symptoms were rarely reported.

John J. Joyce Award
Sponsored by Smith & Nephew Inc.
In 1981, Dr. John J. Joyce III offered a monetary prize for the best arthroscopy paper read by an orthopaedic surgery resident or fellow during the Scientific Program of the 4th Congress of the International Arthroscopy Association in Rio de Janeiro. With characteristic generosity, he endowed a prize to be awarded at every IAA Congress thereafter. John Joyce created the award with the intention to stimulate and reward younger members who contribute high-quality data and presentations. Thus, orthopaedic residents and fellows, with a study related to arthroscopic treatment are encouraged to apply for this award.